CO129-273 - Governor Sir Robinson & Others - 1896 [10-12] — Page 345

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

not see haum in this, but he has two of them any on his Executive Council. He might have discussed the matter and then brought it before the whole Legislative Council in the ordinary way. Nor do I think that his reference to M Chamberlain will be casual.

When the papers as to the Gap Rock rate are referred to M Chamberlain he will carefully consider them. The lateness of the Estimates is a common subject of reasonable complaint for the governor's discussion. It should be remedied in future.

He shows that if the due is to be off there will be a deficit on the 1897 Estimates, but he ought to have contemplated considering the subject and allowed for possible contingencies in the matter, nor did he hint that if the money were taken, it might be possible to meet the deficit by reducing expenditure!

However that may be, we shall hear in due course as to the main subject - how far a governor's pledge should be held binding, & whether the recommendation of 5 out of 6 Unofficial members that the duty should be kept up only for general purposes, not with a view to a specific world, had better be accepted.

The hoist now is the attack on the governor by the other Unofficial members. Whitehead, the cantankerous sixth Unofficial member, complains as to the lateness of the Estimates, a common one & always well founded. The governor says he will attend to it.

His complaint as to private reference to the Unofficial members was discourteous & treasonable as he himself did not treat the reference as material. I think that the answer should be that the question of the procedure on the occasion in point was one part, and M Chamberlain is not inclined to comment upon either Whitehead's representations on the subject at once.

Page 23

CPC

3. Jan

25/1

M

2

Edit History

2026-05-28 04:28:59 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
not see haum in this, but he has two of them any on his Executive Council. He might have discussed the matter and then brought it before the whole Legislative Council in the ordinary way. Nor do I think that his reference to M Chamberlain will be casual. When the papers as to the Gap Rock rate are referred to M Chamberlain he will carefully consider them. The lateness of the Estimates is a common subject of reasonable complaint for the governor's discussion. It should be remedied in future. He shows that if the due is to be off there will be a deficit on the 1897 Estimates, but he ought to have contemplated considering the subject and allowed for possible contingencies in the matter, nor did he hint that if the money were taken, it might be possible to meet the deficit by reducing expenditure! However that may be, we shall hear in due course as to the main subject - how far a governor's pledge should be held binding, & whether the recommendation of 5 out of 6 Unofficial members that the duty should be kept up only for general purposes, not with a view to a specific world, had better be accepted. The hoist now is the attack on the governor by the other Unofficial members. Whitehead, the cantankerous sixth Unofficial member, complains as to the lateness of the Estimates, a common one & always well founded. The governor says he will attend to it. His complaint as to private reference to the Unofficial members was discourteous & treasonable as he himself did not treat the reference as material. I think that the answer should be that the question of the procedure on the occasion in point was one part, and M Chamberlain is not inclined to comment upon either Whitehead's representations on the subject at once. Page 23 CPC 3. Jan 25/1 M 2
Baseline (Original)
not see haum in this, but he has two of them any on his Executive (omail. He might have discussed the matter and then brought it before the M whole Legislation Cormeil in the ordinary way. Nor do I think That his reference Wai When the ha papers as to the Gap Rock rate are refered to M- Chamberlein he will carefully $42 Consider them. The lateness Is a common subject of vasonable is Я the Estimates complaint future for the governor's discation it should be remedied in complaint If the com the skilful. He shows that if deficit on the due is to then off there will be a 1897 Estimates, but he ought ht to have contemplated onsidering the subject had that the time for considering come a to have allowed for possible contingencies in the matter, nor did he hint that if the money were taken, it might be possible to meet the deficit by reducing expenditure! However that may be. We shall hear in due courts as to the main subject - how for a precinct governor's pledge should be held binding, & whether the recommendation the 5 out of 6 thre Unofficial member that the duce (as I understand) should (`ept up- only for general terposes not with a view to a specific world- had better be accepted The hoist now is the attack on by on the other the givernor d 1 members unofficial Wii Whitehead the cantankerous sixth Unofficial His complaint I as to the lateness the Estimates is a common one & always Well founded. The governor says he will attend to it. His complaint as to private reference to the Unofficial members was discounteons & treespery as he himsely did not treat the reference as monte- I think that the answer should be that Years. As The question of the procedure on the Occasion in point was one part and M Chamberlain is not inclined to comment the substance of the foron of a upon either Whiteheads representations on the subject- at once 23. S CPC 3. Jan 25/1 M 2
2026-05-28 04:28:59 · Baseline
View content

not see

haum in this, but he has two of them any on his Executive (omail. He might have discussed the matter and then brought it before the M whole Legislation Cormeil in the ordinary way. Nor do I think

That his reference

Wai

When the ha

papers

as to the Gap Rock rate are refered to M- Chamberlein he will carefully $42 Consider them. The lateness

Is a common subject of vasonable

is

Я

the Estimates

complaint future

for the governor's discation

it should be remedied in complaint

If the com

the

skilful. He shows that if

deficit on

the due is to then off there will be a

1897

Estimates, but he ought

ht to have contemplated onsidering the subject

had

that the time for considering come a to have allowed for possible contingencies in the matter, nor did he hint that if the money were taken, it might be possible to meet the deficit by reducing expenditure!

However that may be. We shall hear in due courts as to the main subject - how for a precinct governor's pledge should be held binding, & whether

the recommendation the 5 out of 6

thre

Unofficial member that the duce (as I understand) should (`ept up- only for general terposes not with a view to a specific world-

had better be accepted

The hoist now is the attack on

by on the other

the givernor d

1

members

unofficial

Wii Whitehead the cantankerous sixth

Unofficial

His complaint

I as to the lateness

the Estimates is a common one & always

Well founded. The governor says

he will attend to it.

His complaint as to private reference to the Unofficial

members was discounteons & treespery as he himsely did not treat the reference as monte- I think that the answer should be that

Years. As The question of the procedure on the

Occasion in point was one

part

and M Chamberlain is not inclined to comment

the substance of the foron of

a

upon either Whiteheads representations on the subject-

at once

23.

S

CPC

3. Jan

25/1

M

2

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.